Personally, if I can get a good pizza in the Lakes region, I will go every week, even if they do close early. Hours are not as important as taste/quality. I have been unable to find any NY style thin crust, any where here. I used to drive an hour to Lincoln to go to Elvio's as they are the only pizza that fit the bill. Sadly, Elvio's was sold and is no more.
Hopefully this is as good as it sounds.
(All that being said, I live here year round. I certainly understand that those of you who vacation here would want places open at night, for when you get up here and want a few pies)
