We,also were torn between Premier and Bennington and even though we love Winnisquam Marine,we settled on the Bennington.They have almost identical features....both tritoons with a 250 o/b.But we liked Benningtons design much better.The stern rails are sloped back to the deck of the boat,giving it a sleek look (if you can call anything about a pontoon boat "sleek"
) all the other "toons" have straight rails that make them look very boxy.
My $.02