As you have canoe experience already, a 15’ or so canoe might be more comfortable to you right off. A canoe would tend to be a dryer deal which matters in cold water. Also a canoe is a little friendlier for fishing in terms of carrying the gear, bait and all those fish. However paddling a canoe solo on a lake when there is some wind is less than fun.
Kayaks are another skill set, lessons help for safety and for efficient paddling. Sit on tops are a wet ride designed for warm water but have no entrapment issue. A closed kayak can be used with a spray skirt to keep dryer but you need to learn the “wet exit” drill. Kayaks are easier to paddle in the wind than a canoe, lower cross section and paddle power on both sides.
Most inexpensive kayaks ($400 to $1,000 and up) are rotomolded plastic and somewhat heavy. Fiberglass kayaks and canoes are much lighter and much more expensive.
There are a lot of trade-offs so what is best for me probably is not best for you. Suggest trying to find a store that sells canoes and kayaks and that has a knowledgeable staff. Kittery Trading Post is one suggestion.
|