We just had a full enclosure completed by Village Canvas and to me, the workmanship was above average, the price was more than fair and he was pleasant to deal with.
I called quite a few places asking for the same exact thing, a full canvas built using my Crownline Bimini top as a base, most places said they could not reuse the top, Village did. Also, when we called to start looking at what we wanted, Bev took the time to walk me through things he could add and things that I wanted and explained why somethings just would not work the way I thought they would. We asked for a lot of clear to be used as I have never had an enclosure for any boat and I was concerned with viability, Bev did a great job keeping as much clear as possible while keeping it durable.
As for a comparison, I do not have one and I guess there is always better or worse for everything. He was easy to work with, worked around my schedule and kept me informed every step of the way. I am happy with the enclosure, it kept me dry in the rain and he did way better than I could have ever done
.