Quote:
Originally Posted by SIKSUKR
Ok,who do I sound like?"How come you guys resort to namecalling with demeaning statements like the above?This must be against the rules of this forum"."That is a libelist comment and you could be sued for slandering me." So Ms rocket scientist,tell me again how 100 Boston Whalers have less carbon footprint than 1 GFBL boat.
|
My "rocket scientist" comment wasn't meant to be an insult in any way to you or to anyone. Did I state or even suggest that you were dumb? Did I state that I was a rocket scientist? No, I didn't do either, so get off my case. My comment was that it should be obvious a large, fast moving boat is using more of the lake surface area than a small, slow moving boat.
And I never made any comment about carbon footprints - so figure that one out yourself.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quote:
Originally Posted by parrothead
A boat does not "consume" water. By consuming you would mean that once a boat passed through a particular area of water, no other vessel could use that water.
|
Consume was not the best choice of words - I was just trying to make a point and I have language issues, so I sometimes don't use the correct word. But your own quoted definition, #7. to
use or use up consumer goods. Boats on a lake are using the water that they sit on or pass through.
Perhaps "Impact" in a better word. In this case "Recreational Impact" is directly related to your "Lake Footprint" (which is determined by using my formula).
----------------------------------------------------------------
Quote:
Originally Posted by chipj29
So tell me again...how does 1 large boat have a larger footprint than 100 smaller boats?
|
Again, the exact number would depend on the variables. But here's an example:
My sea kayak's footprint on the water is around 28 square feet. My friend has the same kayak. And we generally paddle pretty close to each other. Since we never travel faster than no wake speed, we don't have to stay 150 feet from each other, or from any other boat (or the shore, or anything else). So we're each only using 28 square feet of the lake. But, to be fair, I'll add a 5 foot area around each kayak, which increases our footprint to 48 sf.
A 30 x 8 foot powerboat's footprint is 240 square feet. When it is traveling above no wake speed its footprint increases to 17,911 sf, since it now includes the area contained within the 150 foot circle surrounding it.
In this example, the powerboat's footprint equals 373 of our sea kayaks. Is this clear enough for everyone?