Wild Meadow Kayak & Sail, on the Center Harbor-Moultonboro line, has a walkway to the water, and lets you test drive. Finding the right kayak is sort of like buying shoes, best to try it before you buy it.
The shape and design makes a big difference in paddle-ability. Some yaks paddle like floating bathtubs, while others glide along for longer distances.
Prices go from 200 to 2000, new. Plenty of used kayaks out there, too, in the classifieds and yard sales.
Get a comfy kayak, and soon you'll be practicing eskimo rolls!