We served up some marinated tips form the Wine'ing Butcher for the first Saturday of bikeweek, and they were such a hit with the flatlanders, err, out of towners, that I made someone take a special trip the next weekend for more! We've been eating anything we can find there since they opened and they are excellent.
I've also noticed (but have not tried, yet) that the Weirs Beach General Stores new owners also have a deli with marinated tips at a slightly lower price then the Wine'ing Butcher. I plan to try them soon, but the advantage here over the Wine'ing Butcher is the town docks are just down the boardwalk.