Winnipesaukee Forum

Winnipesaukee Forum (https://www.winnipesaukee.com/forums/index.php)
-   Speed Limits (https://www.winnipesaukee.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Hb 162 News (https://www.winnipesaukee.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2696)

pm203 12-01-2005 07:44 PM

Mee n Mac,
I didn,t think that "not being plugged in" was that offensive.I find alot of questionable comments on here that just do not make sense. However, for the good of the forum,I will tone it down and chill out.:)

Bear Islander 12-01-2005 08:04 PM

pm203

If a camp is in Alton Bay for instance, where is the nearest quiet cove? How do the children in sail boats, canoes and row boats get from the camp to the quiet cove without traveling through heavy traffic? How many miles can a 7 year old row a boat to this cove? Many years ago I was the director of a New Hampshire children's camp, thankfully not on Winni. Many times I watched helplessly from shore when speed boats came near my campers.

When you live on a point on Winni, like I do, you can get very nervous when swimmers are in the water. I dislike swimming out further than the end of my dock.

I have neighbors on Bear Island that do not go out in their boats on weekends. I guarantee you this is for real. Just like some people will not drive through Boston during rush hour.

jrc 12-01-2005 08:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mee-n-Mac
I would opine that the insurance companies are the mostly likely supporters for $$ reasons, after all they are a for profit business. With some few exceptions I tend to doubt that legislators, local or state, care all that much. They are caught in the trap of trying to *do something*.

I didn't mean to imply any of the current HB162 support was related to revenue. I'm just predicting that in the future it will be, just like auto tickets clearly are today.

pm203 12-01-2005 08:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bear Islander
pm203

If a camp is in Alton Bay for instance, where is the nearest quiet cove? How do the children in sail boats, canoes and row boats get from the camp to the quiet cove without traveling through heavy traffic? How many miles can a 7 year old row a boat to this cove? Many years ago I was the director of a New Hampshire children's camp, thankfully not on Winni. Many times I watched helplessly from shore when speed boats came near my campers.

When you live on a point on Winni, like I do, you can get very nervous when swimmers are in the water. I dislike swimming out further than the end of my dock.

I have neighbors on Bear Island that do not go out in their boats on weekends. I guarantee you this is for real. Just like some people will not drive through Boston during rush hour.

Yes, your concerns do sound genuine. I as well,would be concerned. I just dont feel that performance boats or speed should be targeted.Everything you described will still be of concern even if all performance boats are eradicated from the lake.Boater education and enforcement of existing laws are a much better way to solve the issue of safety.

Taz 12-01-2005 08:35 PM

I read an article recently that indicated many of the the reps are in favor of amending HB162 by removing the 45 & 25 numbers & changing it to what ever speed is reasonable for the specific situation. If that happens it will take the meat out of the law & those who want to go 60, 70, 80 in the Broads or larger bays will be free to do so.

Thats the way it should be. So high performance owners don't fret.

pm203 12-01-2005 08:37 PM

Common sense will always be common sense.If someone is driving to endanger,citate!

ApS 12-01-2005 08:51 PM

Fer Sale
 
1 Attachment(s)
Ah'm sellin' this here Bass Boat. Nuthin' wrong with it. Jes' takin' bestest offer.
Yuh unnerstan', Ah ain't afeered of nuthin' on Winnipesaukee.
Have Ah got the rite forum?

chase1 12-01-2005 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Taz
I read an article recently that indicated many of the the reps are in favor of amending HB162 by removing the 45 & 25 numbers & changing it to what ever speed is reasonable for the specific situation. If that happens it will take the meat out of the law & those who want to go 60, 70, 80 in the Broads or larger bays will be free to do so.

Thats the way it should be. So high performance owners don't fret.


That is how the current law stands. Do you have a link.

WeirsBeachBoater 12-01-2005 09:54 PM

Not to change the subject
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Acres per Second
Ah'm sellin' this here Bass Boat. Nuthin' wrong with it. Jes' takin' bestest offer.
Yuh unnerstan', Ah ain't afeered of nuthin' on Winnipesaukee.
Have Ah got the rite forum?

But you might have been a victim of the 150' rule in that particular photo. Also not interested in your bass boat, but those ones in the background sure are nice!

BroadHopper 12-01-2005 11:49 PM

Aps
 
Acres per Second. Sounds like you are very contrdictory. Naming yourself 'Acres per second' when you have to go faster than 45 mph to cover an acre per second! :confused:

Woodsy 12-01-2005 11:50 PM

Don... Thanks for what seems like our own little place to debate this hot button topic. It will be nice to debate how to turn lemons into lemonade.

Mee & Mac... well said! I think that everyones opinion should be treated with respect. Both sides of the issue have some very valid points, they just disagree albiet strongly about how to go about it. All sides need to keep the name calling to themselves.

PM203... didn't mean to dump on you, but you got the hint.

Bear Islander... Fear is never a good reason for legislation that limits an individuals personal freedom. It should be that absolute last resort after all else has failed.

I would be careful swimming off your dock as well, especially considering the picture you posted of your own boat driving by it, approximately 4' away, while on plane! Probably traveling at about 25 MPH or so? I also understand that some people don't want to take thier boats out on the weekends because they are afraid. The real question is, afraid of what exactly? Getting hit by a Performance Boat? Or just getting hit by a boat in general? Is it because they have a small boat? Be honest, they are concerned about being hit in general. I doubt boat size matters all that much as long as it is bigger than thier boat. Your little slice of the lake is extremely busy and rough on weekends. A speed limit is going to do nothing to alleviate those conditions. Its also going to do nothing when a noisy boat idles thru the NWZ by the Post Office at 3am, and gets back on plane just past your house either.

A Camp Director should be VERY concerned about ANY powerboats near children that are traveling at ANY speed. That being said, it is his responsibility to make sure the children are safe and after hearing one of them speak, I am sure its a charge they don't take lightly. There are many ways that will help to improve the safety of the children yet not restrict another individuals personal freedom. All of the kids on the water in kayaks or canoes should be in brightly safety orange painted boats with bright orange lifejackets. Perhaps putting in a string of NWZ marker bouys 150' off the camp? I don't think the MP would balk, and certainly I think most, if not all boaters would be for it. Perhaps even help pay for them. The busiest times for boating are friday afternoon until sunday afternoon. The kids are usually at the camps for a week or two at a time. They could limit thier excursions beyond the 150' safety mark to the 4.5 days of the week when the lake isn't busy. They could/should have a larger motorboat idling with the kids as they paddle or sail beyond the 150' safety zone, perhaps flying a big orange flag. Sailboats should be highly visible just because of thier sails, but safety orange sails would be a good thing. Kids who want to go swimming beyond the swim markers should be required to wear a bright orange PFD and not be allowed to venture beyond the proposed 150' NWZ markers. This proposal doesn't infringe on the kids freedom right to enjoy the lake, nor the boaters freedom. It actually makes for a much safer environment for the kids.

APS... Pix can be decieving as all of the boats are pretty much in the same spot. because of this it is very difficult to judge the actual distance between the boats. You can't really judge speed in the pic either. Assuming your pic is correct, I think that education will help to solve thew 150' violation.

EVERYBODY should be REQUIRED to have a SAFE BOATERS CERTIFICATE! NO EXCEPTIONS! My personal freedom should not be infringed upon because a marina owner wants to rent an 1800lb boat for $200/hr to someone who has a credit card with room for a $2500 damage claim, yet posesses no working knowledge of the rules & regulations except for a 20 question quiz and no experience with boat handling!

I think if we restricted boat rentals to those who people who posses a Safe Boaters Certificate, tour companies like the Winni Water Taxi would be a viable, thriving yet safe business.

Woodsy

Mee-n-Mac 12-02-2005 12:28 AM

Thx
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pm203
Mee n Mac,
I didn,t think that "not being plugged in" was that offensive.I find alot of questionable comments on here that just do not make sense. However, for the good of the forum,I will tone it down and chill out.:)

Thanks. It's not that the wording was *offensive* but rather, hmmm let me search for words here, set an inflammatory tone perhaps.... I'd like to understand the fear viewpoint (if only to satisfy my own curiousity) and it's hard to get people to open up if they think it's only going to lead to ridicule. Unfortunately on a topic as emotional as this one is, I'm probably playing the part of Don Quixote in this endevour.

Mee-n-Mac 12-02-2005 01:04 AM

All aboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jrc
I didn't mean to imply any of the current HB162 support was related to revenue. I'm just predicting that in the future it will be, just like auto tickets clearly are today.

Aaah, kinda hard to give up the gravy train once it gets running. ;) There may be another parallel in that once the Federal Gov't was forced to give up on the NMSL/55, the states were left to persue "safety". It took a while but you see less enforcement for simple speeding and more concentration on "agressive driving". I wish they'd hand out more tickets for tailgating.

krwxcr700 12-02-2005 10:21 AM

Where & when was that Pic taken?
 
It looks like my boat. If it was on July 30, 2005 outside of Winter Harbor it is me. The Marine Patrol came by for 1/2 an hour and those boats didn't buzz me at that point but as soon as the MP left it was back to the way the picture is.

Ski Man 12-02-2005 10:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skip
most Courts using the unreasonable speed standard will allow a driver up to and around 15 MPH over the posted limit before convicting. In short, regardless of the posted limit, the officer must show that the speed you were cited for was unreasonable given the prevailing overall conditions at the time of the stop.

Skip,
Can you give any specific examples where a court has released a speeder on this basis? Was this in NH? Where in the statutes or case law is this burden on the officer addressed?

winnilaker 12-02-2005 12:43 PM

NH roads already have this law (Reasonable and Prudent)
 
http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/people/inju...oc/nhspeed.pdf

http://www.gencourt.state.nh.us/rsa/...265/265-60.htm

Commisioner Sweeney (Dept of Safety) testified to the R, R & D to his successful convictions using this law. You might find this interesting, but you can use this law to fight a speeding ticket if you can prove that given the conditions you were driving reasonable and prudent, regardless of the posted speed limit. (This is how Commisioner Sweeney explained it to the committee, not me) For example: a performace car on rt106 traveling at 65 mph and no traffic may be perfectly reasonable and prudent. It can handle and stop better than a minivan and there were no other cars on the road.

Keep this in mind with your next speeding ticket.

winnilaker 12-02-2005 12:51 PM

One more point
 
to highlight this statement in that document

"III. Based on engineering and traffic investigations, a local government may increase or decrease prima facie speed limits within their jurisdictions.4 '265:63, I & II"

Do we have the facts to support "engineering and traffic investigations" which shows 45 mph day and 25 night are the right limits? Or is Pilliod's response that "45 is plenty fast enough to enjoy boating" good enough for law?

jrc 12-02-2005 01:17 PM

two things
 
First we already have this NH law for boating:

270:29-a Careless and Negligent Operation of Boats. – Any person who shall operate a power boat upon any waters of the state in a careless and negligent manner or so that the lives and safety of the public are endangered shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.

This is a misdemeanor, which is much worse than a speeding violation.

Second, getting out of an auto ticket, where you are doing above the posted limit is very tough. In 265:60 you'll find "...any speed in excess of the limit specified in this section or established as hereinafter authorized shall be prima facie evidence that the speed is not reasonable or prudent and that it is unlawful..." then a list of limits. If the posted limits are less than these limits and the local jurisdiction doesn't have the engineering studies to back it up, then you should be able to get off. But that's a very narrow exception.

Skip 12-02-2005 03:23 PM

Speed laws....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ski Man
Skip,
Can you give any specific examples where a court has released a speeder on this basis? Was this in NH? Where in the statutes or case law is this burden on the officer addressed?

There are two basic types of speed laws......prima facie & absolute.

If you go read New Hampshire's speed regulations (RSA 265:60) you will find that exceeding the speed limits posted in most cases is prima facie evidence that you violated the RSA. Therefore most of New Hampshire's speed limits are prima facie limits. Basically, prima facie means "sufficient to establish fact or case unless disproved". That's where the individual cited has an opportunity to go to court and plea his case that the speed cited given the conditions at the time of stop were not unreasonable.

The second type of speed law is absolute. RSA 265:60 makes speeding on the 65 MPH turnpike system an absolute violation by clearly stating that no person shall travel beyond the posted limit. Several surrounding States also have absolute limits, where the State must only prove that you exceeded the limit, not that the exception was unreasonable.

Each Department in New Hampshire is well aware of the preferences of the Court they prosecute in, and each has their own internal guidleines as when to stop a speeder and give that person a warning or summons. There is also great latitude given to the individual officer to use his own discretion when dealing with speeders. There is no "etched in stone" speed windows that you can guarantee yourself a not guilty finding, just general guidelines that officers learn through training and experience.

One of the key points to this whole debate will be how the final law is drafted. Will the 45/25 limits be addressed as prima facie limits or will it be an absolute limit.

Please read RSA 265:60 carefully. I believe the latitude I describe is self evident in its language:

http://www.gencourt.state.nh.us/rsa/...265/265-60.htm

As always, please feel free to PM me if you have any additional questions....

Merry Christmas,

Skip

Dave R 12-02-2005 03:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ski Man
Skip,
Can you give any specific examples where a court has released a speeder on this basis? Was this in NH? Where in the statutes or case law is this burden on the officer addressed?

Happened to me twice while fighting "silly speeding tickets" in court, once in Plaistow and once in Salem. Both times the judge ruled that while he believed I was indeed exceeding the posted limit and I wasn't doing anything unsafe considering the conditions. He was, of course, correct. :D

I won another court battle similarly when I was cited for a double yellow line violation for starting to overtake a few feet before the dashed line started. There was no difference in visibility, just an issue with a painted line being in the wrong place. Why the police officer was so concerned about it was beyond me. That was in Wolfeboro.

Dave R 12-02-2005 04:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Acres per Second
Ah'm sellin' this here Bass Boat. Nuthin' wrong with it. Jes' takin' bestest offer.
Yuh unnerstan', Ah ain't afeered of nuthin' on Winnipesaukee.
Have Ah got the rite forum?

Can't really tell the separation in that photo due to the long lens used. Long lenses compress everything and distort perspective.

Here's a wonderful example of how much the lens can alter the view:
http://www.roshsillars.com/images/compression.gif

chase1 12-02-2005 04:01 PM

If one is to use the argument that our lakes should be subject to a speed limit because we have speed limits on our roadways couldn't you use the same logic and say that we do not need speed limits on our roadways?
Statistics show that more people die in automobiles every year and I am sure some people just are too afraid to drive. I know my grandmother won’t drive anymore because she is scared of those big loud tractor trailers that thunder by at such close range, and loud bikes make her jump. Just think of how much safer your kids would be when playing in the yard if all cars were 150 feet from your property line.
Why don’t we get some rep to sponsor a bill that implements a safe passage law for our roadways and eliminates current speed limits.

FAASS- Family Alliance for Auotmobile Safety and Stuff

Sorry if anyone is offended but I just do not get any of the reasons stated for this proposed law.

If the majority of the population (NH Residents) were uneducated (regarding current safety statistics, laws and experience operating a marine vessels within states inland waterways ) will a democracy yield the best results for government actions.


Chase1

Dave R 12-02-2005 04:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bear Islander
pm203

If a camp is in Alton Bay for instance, where is the nearest quiet cove? How do the children in sail boats, canoes and row boats get from the camp to the quiet cove without traveling through heavy traffic? How many miles can a 7 year old row a boat to this cove? Many years ago I was the director of a New Hampshire children's camp, thankfully not on Winni. Many times I watched helplessly from shore when speed boats came near my campers.

When you live on a point on Winni, like I do, you can get very nervous when swimmers are in the water. I dislike swimming out further than the end of my dock.

I have neighbors on Bear Island that do not go out in their boats on weekends. I guarantee you this is for real. Just like some people will not drive through Boston during rush hour.

Not saying this isn't a problem but it seems like it's already well covered by the no wake/150' laws. Not sure It would make much difference if a swimmer was hit by a boat going 40 MPH or 50 MPH, either would most likely be fatal.

Bear Islander 12-02-2005 04:45 PM

Dave

The speed limit is not about getting boats to go 40 instead of 50. Its about getting them to go 45 instead of 90.

Yes, the swimmer hit by a boat is just as dead at either speed, but you are missing the point. At the slower speed the driver has twice the time to see the swimmer and turn. The swimmer has twice the time to dive or get out of the way.

And with a speed limit, that boat able to go 90 may be in the Atlantic Ocean, where it should be.

Islander 12-02-2005 04:51 PM

Speed Kills
 
It is hard for me to believe that some are arguing that speed has nothing to do with safety. Obviously safety is reduced as speed is increased, anything else is just silly - or denial.

"Speed Kills" is the watchword of every law enforcement agency in the country....... except the NH Marine Patrol!

chase1 12-02-2005 05:54 PM

Bear with me, but why do some feel the GFBL boats will vanish if HB162 passes?????

And with a speed limit, that boat able to go 90 may be in the Atlantic Ocean, where it should be.[/QUOTE]

I am trying to understand but please help me. I have only had positive experiences on the lake.

"where it should be"

Who is to determine where any type of boat should be. Some state rep? The majority? Old man Wilson? Winni is a Big Lake and the arguement could be made that small boats belong on small lakes and if you want your kids to learn how to sail a small boat they should go to one of the many other lakes within our state. Heck many such lakes have had powerboats baned all together so they will be extremely quiet and there no worry regarding boat speed.
Where should the 40' live aboard cabin cruiser be?
Where should the small 18' bass boat be?
Where should the competition ski boat be?
Where should the pontoon boat be?
Where should the 14' scout be?
What about all of the small boats in the Atlantic....By this type of logic they should not be allowed anywhere but the lake. Although I do not agree it may make more sense when you concider how many small boat accidents occur off the coast and in the rivers.
I grew up on a small lake and now boat on Winni. I wanted a bigger type boat so I moved to the big lake. Don't spin this agound. You do not need to have a big boat to be on Winni. I still have small boats too. In fact I summer on an island and run back and forth to the mainland all weekend long on a pontoon boat or small center console. I can not understand anyone who says they can't do that becauyse of the conjestion or GFBL boats.
Boats are made for water and it is the owners who decide where to use them. No manufacture puts a decal on there boat that says use in the ocean or use in lakes.
Speed limit or no speed limit my GFBL will remain on the lake and see the same usage. If gas prices didn't keep my boat at the dock a speed limit won't.

Chase1

Dave R 12-02-2005 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Islander
It is hard for me to believe that some are arguing that speed has nothing to do with safety. Obviously safety is reduced as speed is increased, anything else is just silly - or denial.

"Speed Kills" is the watchword of every law enforcement agency in the country....... except the NH Marine Patrol!

The watchword should really be "speed raises revenue"... You never see speed traps in places where speeding is unsafe. They always seem to be in places where the roads are straight and wide. I hear one can completely flaunt speed limit laws with almost no fear of tickets on curvy narrow back roads if they want to...;)

Speed never killed anyone. Collisions kill. I wonder how many collisions there have been on the lake involving boats where at least one boat is going more than 45 and no laws were broken. Bet the number is quite low, maybe 0. There is no excuse for collisions on the water. They are entirely due to negligence of one sort or another and probably already illegal.

If 45 is twice as safe as 90 then 22.5 must be twice as safe as 45 and 11.25 must be twice as safe as 22.5 and 0 must be infinitely more safe than moving at all. Why 45? I can think of plenty of sitautions where 45 would be legal but entirely unsafe. It's just an arbitrary number that most new boats will just barely exceed.

Cal 12-02-2005 06:48 PM

Most all the reasons FOR a speed limit are really great BUT go ahead and make the speed limit 25 all the time and it won't change most of the concerns stated. Boats will still be close to each other going too fast , they'll still be too close to shore , to close to docks , to close to swimmers , discourteous boater , clueless boaters , the Alton Bay camp director will still have to worry about his kids when they're out in a sail boat ( if he doesn't he better be replaced). Weekends will still be overly crowded. I've been on the lake in a 17 footer on the week end and a speed limit won't change the water conditions with all the boats present. Stop and think for a minute...if you removed all the other boats and left the go fasts , that would eliminate most all the problems previously stated by other people. This of course is not the answer , but mark my words "Neither is a speed limit".
But I guess all of you who are FOR it will have to be shown the truth after it passes:rolleye2:


OK , I'm off my soap box:)

winnilaker 12-02-2005 06:55 PM

Correct but..
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Islander
It is hard for me to believe that some are arguing that speed has nothing to do with safety. Obviously safety is reduced as speed is increased, anything else is just silly - or denial.

"Speed Kills" is the watchword of every law enforcement agency in the country....... except the NH Marine Patrol!

What the difference, that same thinking should tell us to lower our highways to a much lower level. There are many accidents on our roadways and I think if every road in NH had a speed limit of 45 or lower we will have less accidents, yes?

Stating that speed causes safety issues is inaccurate, speed CAN magnify things for sure, but that can be said with anything.

And the Marine Patrol never stated, at least at all the testimonials that I witnessed, that speed cannot be a factor in an accident or cannot kill. Their points are clear, difficult to enforce, no data shows the need and they don't think it will achieve the desired impact. When supporters state "we don't boat anymore because its too rough, therefore we need speed limits to slow everyone down" , you boaters have to clearly see the flaw in that statement.

Ski Man 12-02-2005 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by winnilaker
you can use this law to fight a speeding ticket if you can prove that given the conditions you were driving reasonable and prudent, regardless of the posted speed limit.

The statute clearly states "but any speed in excess of the limit specified in this section or established as hereinafter authorized shall be prima facie evidence that the speed is not reasonable or prudent and that it is unlawful"

The DOT synopsis clearly states that "operating a motor vehicle above the following speed limits is considered prima facie evidence that such speed is unreasonable"

I am unable to find a single case in New Hampshire where a speeding violation was dismissed expressly on the basis that the posted speed limit was less than "reasonable and prudent" because prevailing conditions were ideal, traffic was light, or such. I see numerous cases where bad conditions were used by the police to establish that the speed limit was actually higher than "reasonable and prudent", and to get speeding convictions of those travelling below the posted limit, but not a single case where a speed limit was effectively raised by a court due to optimal conditions or such. Did the Asst Cmm give any particular cases where the "reasonable and prudent, although over the speed limit" argument succeeded in court?

BroadHopper 12-02-2005 07:07 PM

Limits boats.
 
Cal, Once Rep. Pilliod pass this law, he is going to pass another law in limiting the size of boats. The same people who are 'scared' of the go fast boats are also 'scared' of big boat wake. He said to a number of people that the go fast boats and the big cruisers belong on the ocean. I'm surprise that he extended the HB to include the intercoastal waters off NH. 25 mph is maximum wake speed for a lot of boats. Can you imagine the economy that we will be losing???????

A number of boating magazines reported Winnipesaukee as one of the top destination spot. Looks like they will be saying the opposite.

Bear Islander 12-02-2005 07:13 PM

chase1

I do not agree with your statement "Boats are made for water and it is the owners who decide where to use them". The citizens of NH own the lake, and ultimately they decide the boating laws. Shorty their elected representatives will vote on HB162 and we will all have to live with the results.

GFBL boats will not vanish. But over time there will be fewer of them. People have complained in this very forum that they will be trailering elsewhere if HB162 passes.

You ask if a 40' cabin cruiser is OK. I ask where is the limit? Is it 60' or 100' or even 200'? Where is the limit?

How big a wake is to big? How much shore erosion is to much? How much pollution is unhealthy? How much noise is acceptable? How fast is unsafe? There is a limit to everything, and I believe we are there.

Dave R 12-02-2005 08:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bear Islander

You ask if a 40' cabin cruiser is OK. I ask where is the limit? Is it 60' or 100' or even 200'? Where is the limit?

How big a wake is to big? How much shore erosion is to much? How much pollution is unhealthy? How much noise is acceptable? How fast is unsafe? There is a limit to everything, and I believe we are there.

205' to 225' has been OK on the lake for longer than I've been alive. I don't think it's the size of the vessel that matters, it's the manner in which it's operated.

I bet the weather causes vastly more shoreland erosion than wakes. It's pretty relentless. Look at what all the flooding did. Seems like mother nature can and will do a lot more damage to herself than we ever do.

Silver Duck 12-02-2005 08:13 PM

Let's try another tack...
 
..and see if there's any common ground on any part of this issue. So far, all the shootin' seems to be over the 45 mph day time limit. How do you all feel about the proposed 25 mph night time limit?

Personally, I feel that 25 mph is way too fast at night for safe operation (with a few rare exceptions when we have a very bright moon out!) Even with a GPS and a high dgree of familiarity with the lake, I don't like to go up on plane at night, and I've noticed that most of my dockmates prefer to meander along at night, too.

However, I'm also aware that slowing down night time traffic would be a big hassle for island folks (many of whom, by personal observation, are experienced enough with commuting in the dark to run on plane.)

So, what's the general feeling on this topic? Is 25 too slow, too fast, or just about right?

Silver Duck

Mee-n-Mac 12-02-2005 08:28 PM

How fast is too fast
 
Probably not too surprisingly I have some thoughts on what might be reasonable speed limits that I've not previously spewed but now that the flood gates are open, here's some thinking for your consideration ....

The above posts by BI, Islander, Dave R and Winnilaker are interesting because there is a way to begin to reconcile these apparently opposite positions. First I'd like to state a few principles and concepts that I think we all can agree to. First is that everyone should be operating their boat so that it doesn't cause injury to anyone else. Second it is the sole responsibility of the captain to accomplish this. Third any speed limit to be set*, should be set such that the actions of a reasonable person, acting in accordance with the above principles, aren't unlawful. Let me explain the last bit in more detail. Should there be a need to limit speed, the limit isn't set that such a one eyed sailor, blind drunk in his good eye, will always be able to avoid the collision (ie - limit too low). And the flip side is that any limit shouldn't require the operator to be Superman with x-ray vision, reflexes faster than a speeding train, etc, etc. A normal, reasonable, human person has to be able to avoid the collison. Typically these things are set at the 85% percentile, that is 85% of the population can do what's required. Lastly, just as we do on roadways, the limit isn't set according to the worst case environmental conditions. Expounding on this you don't set the posted maximum limit for foggy, raining, etc, conditions. You set for the normal conditions and while what's prudent and reasonable will vary with those conditions, it's the duty of the operator to slow down in accordance with the conditions. The roadway corollary is that when the road is slick with snow, the enforceable limit (you can be stopped and fined) is lower than the posted limit and it's the driver's responsibility to know this.

Given the above, what factors determine whether a collision will occur or not. Certainly the ability to see the hazard is prime and so at what distance can a reasonable person see the hazard ? This is largely independant of speed. Does the available sightline (how far can you see) exceed this distance ? How long will it take the operator to perceive and react to the hazard ? And lastly how much distance does the required control action (slowing or turning or both), to miss the target, take ? Combining all these, at some speed even Superman can't avoid the collision because his sightline is restricted or he, and/or the boat, can't react fast enough. And the other side at some speed even a drunk sailor is virtually guranteed to avoid the collision. In between these 2 speeds is where the reasonable man can avoid the collision and where the speed limit, if necessary, should be set.

Now there are a lot of gray areas and specifics that I've left unsaid but if we can't agree on the general concepts above there's no reason to get into them. *Also I've left out the practical issue of whether a limit, set in accordance with the above, is necessary or will accomplish anything. For the moment let's leave that discussion on the side.

Dave R 12-02-2005 08:29 PM

I would be completely supportive of a law that made it much tougher for negligent and ignorant boaters to get on the water. Imagine if more of us followed the simple and truly unobtrusive boating laws that already exist... If Mr. Pilliod really wants to make the lake less scary, he should educate the ignorant.

I would be much less scared by 90 MPH boats piloted by intelligent and safe boaters, than by 45 MPH boats piloted by folks who have no clue what to do. You?

How about the rest of you, especially those that support the speed limit; where do you think the emphasis belongs? Do you think the marine patrol should use their rescources to enforce speed laws or enforce existing boating laws?

Every hour taken to enforce speed laws is an hour taken away from enforcing 150' laws, performing safety checks, checking for proper boating "Safe Boating Certificates", etc. The supporters of the enforcement of the speed limit law on this forum are, in fact, supporting the reduction of the enforcement of already under-enforced existing laws. Way to go folks... :rolleye2:

Dave R 12-02-2005 08:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Silver Duck

So, what's the general feeling on this topic? Is 25 too slow, too fast, or just about right?

Silver Duck

25 MPH at night seems like a reasonable limit to me. I don't exceed 25 at night but do safely run around 23 MPH (just over the minimum planing speed for my boat) or so, if condition and visibility permit. I don't need a law to tell me that a 35 MPH wind in my eyes is a bad thing at night. I'd still prefer there is no limit though. Would seem to me that most night time accidents probably involve more than just speed, speed and alcohol perhaps?

Dave R 12-02-2005 08:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mee-n-Mac

SNIP

Given the above, what factors determine whether a collision will occur or not. Certainly the ability to see the hazard is prime and so at what distance can a reasonable person see the hazard ? This is largely independant of speed. Does the available sightline (how far can you see) exceed this distance ? How long will it take the operator to perceive and react to the hazard ? And lastly how much distance does the required control action (slowing or turning or both), to miss the target, take ? Combining all these, at some speed even Superman can't avoid the collision because his sightline is restricted or he, and/or the boat, can't react fast enough. And the other side at some speed even a drunk sailor is virtually guranteed to avoid the collision. In between these 2 speeds is where the reasonable man can avoid the collision and where the speed limit, if necessary, should be set.

I agree with you in principle. Still see no need for a limit, yet. Statistics don't show a need and I'd rather see emphasis on fixing other obvious problems like lack of boater ed.

I got my Safe Boater Certificate years before it was required of me and do what I can to teach others safe boating as well. Wish Mr. Pilliod would push for that sort of behavior in the rest of us.

Mee-n-Mac 12-02-2005 08:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Silver Duck
{snip} So, what's the general feeling on this topic? Is 25 too slow, too fast, or just about right?

Silver Duck

I've tried to start to quantify this above but the variables for night boating are much harder to pin down. My experience is that ... it all depends. On a full moon night, where boat hulls are visible at distance, and little to no traffic, I've run 30 - 35. On more normal nights I run 25 - 30. Other times (no skylight, some boats out and about) I've run 20 - 25 and when there's restricted visibility (or leaving the fireworks show) it's NWS. My common run is from Meredith to Alton bay bay so it's long though not particularly difficult. The thing I stress is that when you sight another boat's lights it more difficult (vs daylight) to estimate it's distance and even harder, it's relative course. If the boat isn't identifiable with 2 secs as being "distant" it's time to throttle back and assess the situation.

Pineedles 12-02-2005 10:20 PM

Wow A Speed Record
 
I think this is the most number of posts in the shortest time period that I have seen on the Forum to date. I thought someone said that this wasn't going turn into a frenzied debate as it had previously? :) BTW The autobahn in Germany has no posted speed limits, and it's acccident rate is less than comprable US Highway's accident rate. I believe it is .82 (US) vs. .76 (GE)accidents per 100,000 vehicles. Speed Kills? No, idiots kill, whether they be in boats or cars.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:26 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.