As someone already said here I find it hard to believe that you broke a whip if everything was done correctly. I know people that use whips and have for years with very little problem, and in some very busy parts of the lake.
3 of which live have places with short front on the broads.
During last years hurricane my whips did an excellent job with my boat.
When I see whips break it is generally because along with bending they are twisting. Which means the boat is being allowed to move along the dock to far.
All that said, a lift is the safest. However as mentioned you will not only have the cost of the lift, but it must be put in and out every year.
A mooring is the next best option, there will be some up front cost but yearly maintenance isn't that bad. Make sure you put in a mooring that will accommodate your future boat ambitions.
Whips are going to be the cheapest route. You might also want to incorporate some snubers in the set up as well.
As always ask for help, plenty is always given on the forum...
__________________
Life is about how much time you can spend relaxing... I do it on an island that isn't really an island.....
|